• Home
  • rainbow flagA Welcoming Congregation
  • Safe Congregation SealKeeping Safe
  • Capital Campaign
    • Contact: Capital Campaign
  • DONATE/REALM
  • TUCWomen
    • About TUCWomen
    • Join Us
    • Events
    • Contact
  • Contact
  • Instagram

The Unitarian Church in Westport

10 Lyons Plains Rd., Westport, CT 06880 - Ph: (203)227-7205 Sunday Services: 10:00 AM

uua-logo-2
  • Calendar
    • Calendar
    • SOUNDINGS
    • Communications Guidelines
    • ZOOM Instructions
    • Tips For Making Videos
    • Event & Space Reservations
    • TUCWSocial Email List Ground Rules
  • Welcome Visitors
    • UU Orientation
    • Directions & Services
    • Special Ceremonies & Dedications
    • Our Congregational History
    • Our Faith
    • What is a Unitarian Universalist?
    • We are Unitarian Universalists
    • How did you become a Unitarian Universalist?
    • History of the Flaming Chalice
    • UU History in 8 Minutes
  • About Us
    • Our Mission Statement
    • Our Vision Statement
    • About Our Ministers
    • Our Staff
    • Getting Involved
    • Board of Trustees
    • Governance
    • Congregant Celebration
    • Pastoral Care Chaplains
    • Our Welcoming Congregation
    • Photo & Video Galleries
    • Links – Beyond Our Walls
    • SOUNDINGS
    • Communications Guidelines
    • Events & Space Reservations
    • Pledging
  • FAITH FORMATION
    • Faith Formation 2021-22
    • Welcome to Family Faith Formation
    • This Week in Family Faith Formation
    • What to Expect on Sundays
    • Faith Formation for Children Pre-K through 7th Grade
    • OWL Information at a Glance
    • Considering 8th-9th grade OWL
    • Youth Ministry
    • Adult Faith Formation
    • Soul Matters
    • Keeping Safe
    • Faith Formation Registration
  • Social Justice
    • Welcome to Social Justice
    • Social Justice e-mail
    • Advocates for Prevention of Gun Violence
    • Beardsley School Committee
    • Environmental Action Group
    • Immigration and Refugee Committee
    • KIVA Microfinance Committee
    • Mercy Learning Center Committee
    • Racial Justice Committee
    • Rainbow Task Force
    • Westbridge Coalition
    • UU United Nations Office
    • Additional Programs
    • Racial Justice Resources
  • Music Program
    • Music Choir Schedules
    • Evensong
    • Our Minister of Music
    • The Music Committee
    • The Bell Choir
    • The Choir (Women and Men)
    • Special Projects Choir
    • Once & Again Singers
    • Children’s Choir
    • Teen Choir
    • The Chamber Choir
    • Sight-singing Classes
    • Cabaret
    • Voice Classes
    • Love Is the Spirit
    • Tune My Heart To Sing
    • Support Our Music Program
  • Sermons & Poetry
    • Minister’s Messages
    • Sermons – Audio
    • Sermons – Video
    • Rev. John T. Morehouse’s sermons
    • From Your Senior Minister: Facing Grace
    • Facing Grace – Rev. John’s blog
    • Rev. Frank Hall, Minister Emeritus – sermons
    • Rev. Frank Hall, Minister Emeritus – Dear Friends
    • Intern Minister’s sermons
    • Guest Minister’s sermons
    • Poetry & Readings
    • Communications from Your Ministers

Dear Friends – March 15, 2004

April 20, 2011 by Rev. Frank Hall - Minister Emeritus

Dear Friends,

What a wonderful gift Mel Gibson has given to us. Talk about unintended consequences!

It’s not what he had in mind, to be sure. But that doesn’t take away from the fact that he has gotten more people talking about theology than the publication of Darwin’s The Origin of Species. People are actually taking a look at ‘the origin of the Trinity,’ and they’re often very surprised to discover that Gibson’s theology is rooted in a controversial debate at the Council of Nicea, in the year 325 C.E.

Mel Gibson is a self-described conservative, old-school Roman Catholic. He believes that Jesus is the Christ-the long-awaited Messiah foretold by the Hebrew people, and proclaimed by most of the 300 bishops at the Council of Nicea. They had the biggest debate over the smallest letter. The word homoousias means ‘of the same substance.’ The word homoiousias means ‘of similar substance.’ (Substance, in Greek, is the stuff that God is made of.) Jesus is God, v. Jesus is God-like.

Those who argued for the word homoousias were insisting that Jesus and God are ‘one and the same,’ that there was never a time that Jesus did not exist. Jesus, they argued, was actually God, taking on human flesh, to offer Himself as a sacrifice-the kind brought to the sacrificial altar in\ the Temple. They said, if Christ was not God, then his death for sin was useless, for only God can forgive sins.

At Nicea, Bishop Arius argued against the same-substance doctrine, saying that Jesus was created by God, was the Son of God in a special sense, but there was a time when Jesus did not exist. I think that most Christians, agreeing with Arius, believe that God created Jesus at a point in time and sent him.

Those accused of the Arian heresy were called Unitarians! Only two other bishops sided with Arius–all three were excommunicated. Constantine wrote a letter to the bishops, urging them to put an end to the debate, saying, in part, that the homoousias v. homoiousias debate was, “quarrelling about small and very trifling matters.” He didn’t understand its importance.

Gibson and I agree on only one thing: it’s not ‘a small and trifling matter.’ Gibson believes that Jesus was God. I don’t. I believe that Jesus was completely human-his suffering was human suffering, which we all share. It comes with the human package. God, by definition, is immortal.

Gibson has stirred up the old controversy. William Safire says, “Mel Gibson ‘s movie about the torture and agony of the final hours of Jesus is the bloodiest, most brutal example of sustained sadism ever presented on the screen.” Maureen Dowd calls Gibson’s film, “Stations of the Crass.” James Carroll calls it ‘obscene.’ A friend who is a Catholic priest wrote to me, ” Deep down I really feel that only a Catholic can love this movie-and an old-time Catholic at that.” He said he loved the film, but as a piece of inspiring art. “The violence becomes more and more a Jackson Pollack canvas.”

I’ve won’t impugn Mel Gibson’s motives. He’s entitled to his religious beliefs. He’s helping us to look into the Biblical roots of anti-Semitism. He didn’t intend that, either. The Biblical story blames the Jews for Deicide, and in recent years most Christians have tried to teach their believers that it’s wrong to blame Jews for the death of Christ. Unintended consequence: Gibson goes to seminary!

This is the longest introduction to an up-coming sermon I’ve ever given. Thanks, Mel. We’ll continue on Sunday. I hope to see you, and I hope you’re feeling better, now.

Cheers,
Frank

Filed Under: Dear Friends

  • Minister’s Messages
  • Sermons – Audio
  • Sermons – Video
  • Rev. John T. Morehouse’s sermons
  • From Your Senior Minister: Facing Grace
  • Facing Grace – Rev. John’s blog
  • Rev. Frank Hall, Minister Emeritus – sermons
  • Rev. Frank Hall, Minister Emeritus – Dear Friends
  • Intern Minister’s sermons
  • Guest Minister’s sermons
  • Readings & Poetry
  • Communications from Your Ministers

     The Unitarian Church in Westport
     is a member congregation of the
     Unitarian Universalist Association

      CLICK HERE if you have any questions      about The Unitarian Church in Westport

Church Hours: Tuesday - Friday
9:30 AM to 4:00 PM

Summer Hours:
July & August until after Labor Day:
Tuesday - Friday 9:30 AM to 4:00 PM

CLICK HERE to contact the web master

CLICK HERE to opt in to receive
the Weekly Congregational Email Blast

Copyright © 2022 · Visit us at The Unitarian Church in Westport - 10 Lyons Plains Rd., Westport, CT 06880 - All rights reserved.